Today, we had a busy day. Both kids wanted to see the new Hannah Montana movie. So we went to the first showing at 12:30. They both had a blast. Bridget's favorite part of the movie was the 'behind the scenes' shots, while Owen enjoyed seeing and hearing his favorite songs. My favorite part was that my Mother-In-Law accompanied us and graciously offered to foot the bill for the tickets.
On the way home in the car, Bridget was gushing about what a wonderful day she had. "Mommy this was the best day ever. And it is all because you planned it. You made this day perfect. Thank you for all your hard work. This was the best day of my whole life and it all happened because of you...." I acknowledged her thanks and tried to focus on the fact that her enjoying herself was the most important part. I suggested that maybe the theme song from "Happy Days" should be our theme song to help us remember what is important. It definitely made me take notice that I complain to the kids about planning things (when they don't want to cooperate). Also, we still have a lot of work to do to eliminate the praise mentality from our home.
When we got home the kids were in the highest of spirits. E asked them how their day went. Bridget said, "Not so good. Look, I stubbed my toe really bad." E, of course, winced in disgust (he's not a blood person) and she got the shocking response she was looking for. What happened to 'best day of my life'? Where did all that joy and excitement go? Where did this Mr. Hyde come from? Another reminder to me that her joy in the car seemed 'drummed up' just to make me feel appreciated. She gave E an accurate account of the joys and sadness of her day, but I had to be praised. Yikes. I tremble at the thought of what my kids must think of me.
4 comments:
What do you mean when you say you need to "eliminate the praise mentality from our home"? Why is praise a negative thing?
Stacie,
On the right hand side of my blog under 'What I've been reading', check out Punished By Rewards by Alfie Kohn. Rewards and praise are forms of manipulation just like criticism and punishment. It is not intuitive, but the book explains how praise and criticism have the same effect in the long run. As an unschooler I am trying to stop judging, manipulating and reacting to my children's behaviors. Instead I hope to connect with them and help them choose behaviors on their own that will make them happy in the long run.
I agree that bribing and coercing, rewards and even grades are/can be negative things. But appreciation, encouragement and praise can do wonders for a person's self-esteem, and I've always found it to be very beneficial to Levi.
I agree that appreciation and encouragement are good and necessary things, but Kohn explains how praise is different.
Post a Comment